Hollie was amazing this week! Jessica not so much.

They are both sooo good. But together they are beyond amazing. One of them should've won.

Jessica is amazing jimmy was right Hollie is stiff and is straining but jessica is amazing oh and I hate Maggie pants because she's a ?!&"$@

whoever arrange this song for both singers didn't do it right. they made hollie the front singer and jessica the back-up. thats why hollie sounds great on this song because you can hear her voice, while jessica's voice is blending with the other back-up voices. they even had her sing the lower note so hollie can sing the average note...

Good song and would be better without Jessica.

I think their voices blended really well. I love this rendition-can't understand why Randy didn't like it

Well, i glad it didnt turn out holly dreaming into a nightmare! Good Job Jessica Sanchez. You are 11th American idol! i bought all of your songs except this though( cause holly voice making me fuke) sorry ;(

Hollie was never that good. Jessica was always great. Jessica did great on this song! Hollie did not.

They were the best Hollie went home though:( she was my fav. So now Jessica better win

Huge Jessica fan but Hollie sounded really great on this one too!